Lipiflow May Help Symptoms of Blepharochalasis

Blepharochalasis is a not too common condition thought to be a familial variant of angioneurotic edema (ie, swelling under the skin: more info below at end of blog post **). The exact cause is not known. It tends to occur in younger women (compared to Dermatochalasis–sounds the same but in older patients with lax upper eyelid skin that can sag). 

                          

Signs of Blepharochalasis:

-cigarette paper skin (eg, wrinkly skin)

-relapsing and remitting edema (eg, swelling comes & goest)

-subcutaneous telangiectasia (eg, fine red lines under skin)

This is a patient before eyelid surgery called blepharoplasty for the Blepharochalasis

There are few treatment options Blepharochalasis.  If it is due to an allergy or anything in the below Differential Diagnosis, it can be easier to remedy. Blepharochalasis is more of a diagnosis of exclusion: if you exclude most of the below, it is likely Blepharochalasis. 

Differential diagnosis (eg, what to think about and consider ruling out):

What can maybe make Blepharochalasis worse potentially:

1. Aging

2. Hormonal changes

3. Stress

4. Allergies

5. Diet

Treatment:

There is no established treatment protocol for blepharochalasis.

Studies have shown the below do not help:

-Systemic or topical steroids, 

-Antihistamines and other anti-inflammatory agents 

Experimental treatments have been reported in the literature:

1. Oral doxycycline (inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinases): 

a. 2 patients reported to improve eyelid edema and prevent recurrent attacks: 50 mg po bid initially, then tapered to 25 mg po qod

b. there are no trials to evaluate the safety and efficacy of long term use of doxycycline in blepharochalasis syndrome.

2. Oral sustained release acetazolamide: 

a. 250 mg po qd reduced periorbital edema and lid discomfort in a patient who refused surgery and failed treatment with oral 

b. side effects caused drug acetazolamide to be discontinued after a short course.

3. Surgery may help, but may not be a cure. The difference in the above photos was minimal but the patient may have been very happy. 

***4. Lipiflow or Thermal Pulsation: I have had 2 patients who feel Lipiflow helped their Blepharochalasis. This has not been reported as of yet. If we get another couple of patients who report this, we will publish this observation. Lipiflow is very low risk. NO surgery required. NO steroids required. There have been no studies to evaluate meibography with symptoms of Blepharochalasis. It could be there is a relationship and Lipiflow milks out clogged oil which can lead to less swelling. Or Lipiflow decreases inflammation within the lid or ocular surface, which then leads to improvement. A prospective, double blind study would need to be done but that will take years as it is hard to do thermal pulsation/Lipiflow only on 1 eye’s eyelids. 

References: 

Abstract

Eyelid bags and blepharochalasis are the result of relaxation of lid structures like the skin, the orbicularis oculi, and mainly the orbital septum. Therefore, this aged appearance cannot be improved sufficiently with only a skin and orbicularis oculi resection. To improve this appearance, we use a very effective method of tucking of the orbital septum with infraeyebrow excision of the skin and the orbicularis oculi. Between January 2005 and April 2011, 103 patients (206 lids) were treated. There were 89 female and 14 male patients whose ages ranged from 43 to 75 years (mean = 65.2 years). After infraeyebrow excision, blepharoplasty with tucking of the orbital septum, the concealed lid crease becomes apparent and a good rejuvenation effect is obtained in all patients.

2.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blepharochalasis#:~:text=Blepharochalasis%20is%20an%20inflammation%20of,folds%20over%20the%20lid%20margins.

https://eyewiki.aao.org/Blepharochalasis_Syndrome

Disease Entity

Blepharochalasis or blepharochalasis syndrome is a rare condition characterized by episodic inflammation of the eyelids.

Disease

This condition was initially described by Beer in 1817, but the term blepharochalasis was assigned to this entity by Fuchs in 1896. [1] This disorder typically affects the upper eyelids and usually occurs bilaterally, though rare cases of unilateral presentations and lower eyelid involvement have been reported.

Stages of blepharochasis syndrome including an active intumescent phase during which attacks of non-pitting edema will occur, and a subsequent atrophic, quiescent phase characterized by the absence of attacks for two years and paper-thin, baggy eyelid skin, have been described. [1] [2] Attacks often last two to three days but this is highly variable between patients. The frequency of edema attacks is usually in the range of three to four episodes per year early in the disease course. [2]

Etiology

Unlike dermatochalasis which may often be confused with this disorder and is an involutional change of the eyelid, blepharochalasis is thought to be a familial variant of angioneurotic edema. While the exact underlying cause is not known, there have been multiple systemic associations described. A link to Asher’s syndrome, a rare condition characterized by attacks of upper eyelid and lip edema with or without euthyroid goiter, has been suggested.[1] Other theories suggest hormonal changes especially during puberty, upper respiratory tract infections, and allergies may also play a role in the disease process.

Epidemiology

Because it is a rare syndrome, minimal epidemiologic data is available. Blepharochalasis has been reported more in females, though it is thought that it affects both genders at similar rates. Patients report more frequent attacks during adolescence or young adulthood followed by less frequent attacks during adulthood.

General Pathology

The underlying pathology has not been studied extensively for this disease process. However, several case reports have demonstrated distinct findings in the affected eyelid tissues at the cellular level supporting an underlying immunopathogenic process. Eyelid biopsy in a single patient with blepharochalasis revealed perivascular and interstitial infiltration of lymphocytes in the dermis associated with a marked decrease in elastic fibers. Staining of MMP-3 and MMP-9 was detected in and around infiltrating cells in the dermis. [3] In another study, abundant IgA deposits surrounding atrophic elastic fibers in the eyelid skin of a patient was reported, while these deposits were absent in a control sample of a remote skin biopsy site. [4]

Pathophysiology

Several theories regarding the pathogenesis and pathophysiology of blepharochalasis have been explored, though none has been confirmed. The episodic eyelid edema which regresses spontaneously may be suggestive of idiopathic angioedema, wherein extravasation of fluid from capillaries causes localized edema. The result is stretched, atrophic tissue. However, perivascular infiltrates which have been reported on histologic examination of eyelid tissue in patients with blepharochalasis may support an alternative or concomitant inflammatory process. [2] Why this inflammation or idiopathic angioedema is confined to the eyelids also remains unknown.

Diagnosis

History

Patients will frequently describe attacks of painless eyelid swelling, sometimes associated with erythema. In most cases, triggers are not identified. Some may report stressful events preceding attacks of edema, or a history of allergy. [1] Other reported triggering factors include crying, bee sting, fever, wind and physical activity. [2]

Physical examination

Blepharochalasis is a clinical diagnosis. In the acute phase, characteristic findings eyelid edema, erythema, and conjunctival injection. A wide variety of physical exam findings may be present and include:[1]

• “Cigarette paper” or finely wrinkled skin
• Severe eyelid skin thinning
• Lax eyelid skin which may obstruct vision
• Entropion and ectropion
• Subcutaneous telangectasia
• Pigmentary skin changes
• Levator dehiscence ptosis
• Orbital fat prolapse
• Lacrimal gland prolapse
• Pseudoepicanthal fold with atrophy of the nasal fat pad
• Proptosis

Laboratory test

Laboratory studies do not currently play a role in the diagnosis of blepharochalasis syndrome.

Differential diagnosis

Dermatochalasis, which refers to lax or redundant upper eyelid skin commonly associated with aging, may be confused with blepharochalasis. However, dermatochalasis is not associated with the characteristic findings of blepharochalasis, namely cigarette paper skin, relapsing and remitting edema, and subcutaneous telangiectasia. [1] Patients with dermatochalasis will also tend to be older than those affected by blepharochalasis.

Other diagnoses to consider would include thyroid eye disease, floppy eyelid syndrome, orbital cellulitis, sarcoidosis, idiopathic orbital inflammation, hereditary angioedema, dacryoadenitis, lacrimal gland tumor, and localized cutis laxa.[1]

Management

Medical therapy

There is no established treatment protocol for blepharochalasis. Systemic or topical steroids, antihistamines and other anti-inflammatory agents have not been shown to play a role in acute attacks or in the overall disease course.

Experimental treatments have been reported in the literature. Oral doxycycline, a known inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinases, has been described in a case report of two patients to improve eyelid edema and prevent recurrent attacks. The patients were treated with a dose of 50 mg po bid initially, then tapered to 25 mg po qod. [5] However, there have been no trials to evaluate the safety and efficacy of long term use of doxycycline in blepharochalasis syndrome.

In another case report, oral sustained release acetazolamide at a dose of 250 mg po qd reduced periorbital edema and lid discomfort in a patient who refused surgery and failed treatment with oral corticosteroids. [6] Given the side effect profile of acetazolamide, the drug was discontinued after a short course.

Surgery

Surgical interventions are aimed at correcting the complications of blepharochalasis, most commonly ptosis and eyelid skin laxity. Surgical correction should be delayed until late in the disease course when attacks have become infrequent. Disease quiescence for six to twelve months is recommended prior to surgery. [1] [2]

Blepharoplasty, levator aponeurosis dehiscence repair, eyelid tightening, canthal tendon reattachment, and fat grafting may all be considered for these patients.

Unfortunately, the same inflammatory process which results in the blepharochalasis may cause ptosis and eyelid skin laxity to recur after surgical repair. [7] Patients should, therefore, be counseled appropriately.

Complications

Ptosis, herniation of the orbital lobe of the lacrimal gland, prominent eyelid vascularity, and orbital fat pad atrophy are all complications which may arise from this condition. [7]

Prognosis

There is insufficient data regarding changes in the frequency of attacks prior to and following surgery. Treatments in the future will likely be aimed at preventing the condition and the complications associated with this disorder ultimately to avoiding the need for surgical correction of these sequelae.

References

1. ↑ Jump up to:1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 Kotlus B. Blepharochalasis syndrome. http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1214014-overview#a9. Mar 23, 2015.
2. ↑ Jump up to:2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Koursh DM et al. The blepharochalasis syndrome. Surv Ophthalmol. 2009 Mar-Apr;54(2):235-44.
3. Jump up↑ Motegi S et al. Blepharochalasis: possibly associated with matrix metalloproteinases. J Dermatol. 2014 Jun;41(6):536-8.
4. Jump up↑ Grasseger A et al. Immunoglobulin A (IgA) deposits in lesional skin of a patient with blepharochalasis. Br J Dermatol. 1996 Nov;135(5):791-5.
5. Jump up↑ Karaconji T et al. Doxycycline for treatment of blepharochalasis via inhibition of matrix metalloproteinases. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg. 2012 May-Jun;28(3):e76-8.
6. Jump up↑ Lazaridou MN, Sanding T and Kemp EG. Oral acetazolamide: A treatment option for blepharochalasis? Clin Ophthalmol. 2007 Sep; 1(3): 331–333.
7. ↑ Jump up to:7.0 7.1 Basic Clinical Science Series. Orbit, Eyelids, and Lacrimal System. American Academy of Ophthalmology. 2014-2015